Considerations For Using Large Diameter Coriolis Mass Flowmeters In Oil & Gas Applications
During the last decade manufacturers have been launching larger Coriolis mass flowmeters to satisfy the requirement for mass flow measurement in larger line sizes for bulk fluid transfer applications in oil and gas, chemical or petrochemical industry segments. The high performance mass flow and density accuracy specifications of Coriolis flowmeters have made this technology increasingly popular in both new installations and also when replacing traditional flowmeter technologies.
The designs of these large line size meters are very different
as compared to smaller diameter offerings and also from each other. In Figure 1 you can see two popular types of designs featuring straight and bent tubes. Both designs are quite substantial in order to accommodate the bigger flow tube diameters needed to achieve higher flow rates. The straight tube design offers higher flowrates with the lowest pressure drop. The twin bent tube design is used for high temperature, cryogenic and high pressure applications.
The two or four straight tube design fits the pipeline perfectly and comes with optimized flow splitters. There are many advantages for straight tube designs over bent tube designs, as the diameter increases to achieve higher flow rates, the footprint size becomes larger and the weight increases proportionally. Bent tube designs create installation and design challenges for the user companies, engineering firms or for measurement skid integrators and fabricators while straight tube designs are easier to install.
Installations requirements differ according to the meter design. With bent tube meters there are two basic options; either horizontally, with the bends parallel or perpendicular to the ground, or vertically in the “flag position”, with the bends flaring out from the pipe.
Let’s consider the U-shaped meter in a horizontal installation on liquids. In this condition, to keep the meter full of liquid and avoid gas pockets, you would install the meter with the tube’s bend perpendicular to the ground and below the flow pipe. Often there is a challenge for a U-shape design since pipelines are mostly only a few feet above the ground. There is no space to put the meter’s “belly” in this situation unless expensive civil engineering and construction is expended to dig a sump to accommodate the meter. Keeping the sump clean of debris, water or ice and snow would then be an extra consideration since you would not want to have the meter submerged in any way.
Where two parallel pipelines are close to each other it’s also difficult to install either the round design or U-shaped meters in a horizontal position since there is not enough space for the bellies between two parallel pipes. A pipe outbreak would be required to install these meters in a horizontal position. For the U-shaped design, the flag position will increase the footprint of the measurement skid significantly and makes construction and installation of the measurement skid more expensive and difficult. Additionally, added mass in the meter itself may cause mechanical stresses on the measurement tubes when mounted vertically resulting in noise and potentially inaccurate measurement.
Flowmeters in custody transfer applications have to be proven in the field frequently. The proving is mostly done through Small Volume Provers (SVP). An SVP pushes a known “small” volume through the meter and the pulses of the flowmeter are counted. Every missed pulse can influence the uncertainty and repeatability negatively. For good proving results, a very consistent zero stability is key. Zero stability is an indication of the consistent performance of a filled flowmeter in zero flow conditions. Noise and mechanical tension on the measuring tubes influences the zero stability which can lead to poor proving results.
What the market needs
Upon evaluation of the market needs, the most common request is for a small installation envelope and mounting flexibility. Being able to install meters in close proximity to other pipes or without having to adapt other equipment such as catwalks or platforms would help optimize a package design and reduce costs associated with transport.
The design should also easily adapt to any mounting requirements, whether vertically or horizontally or anywhere in between, with no influence on the accuracy and zero stability of the meter and without mechanical stress on the measurement components.
Other needs include suitability for the environment such as hazardous area approvals; traceable calibrations; secondary containment; custody transfer performance with field proving using small volume provers, and a wide variety of communications options and diagnostics tools.
KROHNE recently launched their newest addition to the OPTIMASS family. It is a large diameter Coriolis mass
flowmeter that features four straight tubes with the smallest installation envelope of its class.
With a maximum measurement range of 695,000 Barrels per day, it features the highest flow capacity of any Coriolis meter on the market.
As shown in Figures 2 and 6, its unique cylindrical straight tube configuration allows it to be installed like any other piece of pipework due to the rigid secondary containment housing design which can handle pressures up to 2175 psig. Also, upstream and downstream runs are not required since Coriolis meters are independent of the Reynolds number and flow profile effects.
Accurate and reliable measurement is possible in very compact measurement skids and this alone can result in very, very significant savings in construction, installation and transportation costs to the end customer.
Pumping liquids through a large line size bent tube Coriolis mass
flowmeter in the flag position causes a large pressure drop which
results in high pumping costs over the year. KROHNE’s four straight
tube Coriolis mass flowmeter with the optimized flow splitter design
(Figure 3) reduces these pumping costs and also benefits the user with
As previously mentioned, to measure bulk flowrates accurately a Coriolis mass flowmeter requires a very good zero stability. KROHNE mechanically isolates the measuring tubes of the meter from the process using their patented node plate technology. The node plates dampen any kind of vibration and noise in the process. Stresses caused by torque from piping offsets are redirected over the outer casing of the meter, which is constructed of schedule 160 pipe, to prevent the meter accuracy from being affected.
The node plate technology shown in Figure 4 was first used in dual tube flowmeters and was migrated
into the new four straight tube Coriolis mass flowmeter. The isolation is so effective that if necessary the
meter can be clamped directly at the meter body to support the weight of the meter.
It takes a very big calibration rig to calibrate the largest available Coriolis Mass flowmeters. At the KROHNE production facility in Wellingborough in the UK, where KROHNE’s center of excellence for Coriolis Mass flowmeters is located, they developed the largest mass flow calibration rig in the world to take on this challenge.
To calibrate a flowmeter to ±0.05% accredited measurement uncertainty, the calibration rig has to be at least three times more accurate.
The new large mass flow calibration rigs are accredited by UKAS 0812 according to ISO 17025, England’s metrology agency, to an uncertainty of less than 0.017%.
The new calibration rigs allow for calibration of the OPTIMASS 2400 S400 16 inch Coriolis Mass flowmeter with flows to 60% of the nominal meter capacity. As shown in Figure 5, this flow rig is the single largest one of its type in the world.
Highlights of the OPTIMASS 2400 S400:
• Innovative four measuring tubes design with a large tube size, high flow capacity
• High accuracy for custody transfer
• Easy to drain and easy to clean
• Optimized flow splitter for minimum pressure drop
• Super Duplex option for operating pressures up to 180 barg; 2,610 psig
• Secondary containment up to 150 barg; 2,175 psig